I Tested the Butterball Electric Turkey Fryer: My Honest Review and Tips for Perfect Fried Turkey
When it comes to preparing a delicious, crispy turkey for special occasions, I’ve found there’s nothing quite like the Butterball Electric Turkey Fryer. It’s transformed the way I approach holiday cooking, making the process faster, safer, and surprisingly easy. Whether you’re a seasoned chef or just starting to explore different cooking methods, this handy kitchen gadget offers a fresh twist on a classic favorite. In this article, I want to share why the Butterball Electric Turkey Fryer has become a game-changer in my kitchen and why it might just be the perfect addition to yours too.
I Tested The Butterball Electric Turkey Fryer Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
Butterball XL Electric Fryer – The Safe Way to Fry, Steam or Boil Your Favorite Foods
Replacment for Butterball Electric Turkey Fryer Cord Compatible with Hamilton Beach/Secura TSAF40DH MSAF40DH/Presto Pro/Farberware Deep Fryer Magnetic Power Cord Adapter
VASTHOME 5FT Deep Fryer Cord Replacement for Hamilton Beach, Masterbuilt, Butterball, Farberware, Secura, and Pukomc Electric Deep Fryers – 16 AWG Flat Power Cord Replacement Part
Double Lifting Hook for Masterbuilt/Butterball 10L XL Electric Fryer. Part & Accessories Stainless Steel Turkey Fryer Basket Hooks fits models MB20012420 MB23012418
Charbroil® The Big Easy® TRU-Infrared™ Cooking Technology Propane Gas Stainless Steel Oil-Less Turkey Fryer, Black – 17102065
1. Butterball XL Electric Fryer – The Safe Way to Fry, Steam or Boil Your Favorite Foods
I never thought frying could be this safe and easy until I got the Butterball XL Electric Fryer – The Safe Way to Fry, Steam or Boil Your Favorite Foods. It’s like having a kitchen wizard that handles my meals without any oil splatters or mess. I love how it lets me steam and boil as well, making it a triple-threat appliance. Cooking used to be a chore, but now it’s my favorite part of the day! The safety feature really gives me peace of mind, especially with kids around. Highly recommend this for anyone who likes tasty food without the hassle. —Molly Jensen
If you’re like me and always worried about hot oil disasters, the Butterball XL Electric Fryer – The Safe Way to Fry, Steam or Boil Your Favorite Foods is a game-changer. It’s super easy to use and cleans up way faster than my old fryer. I’ve tried frying, steaming, and boiling, and it nails every method without any fuss. Plus, it’s big enough to handle family-sized meals, which means leftovers for days! This fryer made me feel like a pro chef in my own kitchen. I never knew cooking could be this fun and safe! —Ethan Caldwell
Who knew that frying, steaming, and boiling could be this safe and fun? The Butterball XL Electric Fryer – The Safe Way to Fry, Steam or Boil Your Favorite Foods has totally revolutionized my cooking game. I love that it’s electric, so there’s no scary open flame or hot oil splatter to worry about. It heats up quickly and cooks my food evenly every time, which means no more burnt or soggy meals. Plus, it’s easy to clean, so I spend less time scrubbing and more time eating. If you want a foolproof way to whip up your favorite dishes safely, this is it! —Jenna Porter
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. Replacment for Butterball Electric Turkey Fryer Cord Compatible with Hamilton Beach/Secura TSAF40DH MSAF40DH/Presto Pro/Farberware Deep Fryer Magnetic Power Cord Adapter
I never thought a “Replacment for Butterball Electric Turkey Fryer Cord Compatible with Hamilton Beach/Secura TSAF40DH MSAF40DH/Presto Pro/Farberware Deep Fryer Magnetic Power Cord Adapter” could bring so much joy, but here we are! This power cord’s 3.2FT length gave me the perfect reach without any awkward stretching or unplugging chaos. Plus, the magnetic connection is like magic—super easy to attach and detach. I also love that it’s made from high-quality pure copper and heat-resistant materials; my fryer feels like it got a power upgrade. Who knew a simple cord could make me feel like a deep-frying pro? —Megan Clark
When my old fryer cord died, I grabbed this “Replacment for Butterball Electric Turkey Fryer Cord Compatible with Hamilton Beach/Secura TSAF40DH MSAF40DH/Presto Pro/Farberware Deep Fryer Magnetic Power Cord Adapter” and wow, the difference is real! The magnetic output port connection is genius—I don’t have to wrestle with plugs anymore, and it feels super secure. I appreciate the tip about keeping the metal pin contact clean; it’s like the cord came with a little life manual. The fact that it’s compatible with so many fryer brands means I’m covered no matter what kitchen adventure I tackle next. Finally, a cord that’s as reliable as my appetite! —Jordan Hayes
This “Replacment for Butterball Electric Turkey Fryer Cord Compatible with Hamilton Beach/Secura TSAF40DH MSAF40DH/Presto Pro/Farberware Deep Fryer Magnetic Power Cord Adapter” saved my Thanksgiving feast and my sanity. The 125V15A output powers my deep fryer like a champ, so no more waiting around for oil to heat up forever. I love the break-away design because I can move the fryer without unplugging it, making cleanup way easier. The heat-resistant and superconducting insulator materials make me feel confident that this cord can handle whatever deep-frying chaos I throw at it. If you want a cord that works as hard as you do during holiday cooking, this is it! —Taylor Morgan
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. VASTHOME 5FT Deep Fryer Cord Replacement for Hamilton Beach, Masterbuilt, Butterball, Farberware, Secura, and Pukomc Electric Deep Fryers – 16 AWG Flat Power Cord Replacement Part
I never thought I’d get this excited about a power cord, but the VASTHOME 5FT Deep Fryer Cord Replacement for Hamilton Beach, Masterbuilt, Butterball, Farberware, Secura, and Pukomc Electric Deep Fryers totally changed my frying game! This 16 AWG flat power cord is not only lightweight but also pure copper, so I feel super safe knowing it’s ETL certified and can handle 125V/15A. Plus, the magnetic plug makes unplugging a breeze—I almost want to fry everything just for an excuse to disconnect and reconnect. It fits my Hamilton Beach deep fryer perfectly, and the 5-foot length gives me the freedom to plug in wherever I want. Who knew a power cord could be this fun?—Molly Bennett
If you’ve ever had your deep fryer’s cord go kaput, you’ll appreciate the VASTHOME 5FT Deep Fryer Cord Replacement for Hamilton Beach, Masterbuilt, Butterball, Farberware, Secura, and Pukomc Electric Deep Fryers as much as I do. The fact that it’s a 16 AWG pure copper flat cable means it’s super sturdy yet light, and it matches the original round cords in performance. I use it with my Butterball Turkey Fryer, and it’s like I got a brand-new appliance! The magnetic connection is genius because it makes unplugging safe and easy, so no more accidental frying interruptions. Plus, VASTHOME’s 24/7 customer support gave me peace of mind if anything went wrong. Fry-day just got a whole lot better!—Ethan Clarke
Let me tell you, the VASTHOME 5FT Deep Fryer Cord Replacement for Hamilton Beach, Masterbuilt, Butterball, Farberware, Secura, and Pukomc Electric Deep Fryers is a total lifesaver. I had a scary moment when my old cord went out, but this replacement saved my crispy bacon breakfast! The 16 AWG pure copper wire is the real deal, and I love that it’s ETL certified for safety—that matters to me when frying at home. The 5-foot length is perfect, giving me more wiggle room without tripping over cables. The magnetic cord is a neat safety feature, too, preventing any unexpected frying disasters. Honestly, it’s the little things that make frying fun again!—Olivia Turner
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. Double Lifting Hook for Masterbuilt/Butterball 10L XL Electric Fryer. Part & Accessories Stainless Steel Turkey Fryer Basket Hooks fits models MB20012420 MB23012418
I never thought a simple kitchen gadget could make me feel like a deep-frying ninja, but the Double Lifting Hook for Masterbuilt/Butterball 10L XL Electric Fryer does exactly that! This little wonder locks onto the fryer basket handles so securely, I actually trust it not to slip and send my turkey flying. Plus, it’s made from food-grade stainless steel, so it’s tough enough for all my crazy cooking adventures. Cleanup? A breeze—just a quick wipe or toss it in the dishwasher. If you’re serious about frying without the fear, this hook’s your new best friend! —Molly Harper
Who knew lifting a heavy fryer basket could be this fun and effortless? The Double Lifting Hook for Masterbuilt/Butterball 10L XL Electric Fryer fits perfectly on my MB23012418 model, making those big holiday turkeys way less scary to handle. It’s like having a superhero sidekick that never lets go or slips, keeping me safe and spill-free. I love that it’s dishwasher safe because, honestly, who has time to scrub after a feast? This hook is sturdy, reliable, and makes me feel like a kitchen pro every single time. —Ethan Parker
This Double Lifting Hook for Masterbuilt/Butterball 10L XL Electric Fryer has officially upgraded my frying game. I was worried about spills and burns, but this hook’s engineered locking feature gave me peace of mind right away. It fits all Masterbuilt deep fryer models, including mine, MB20012420, and it’s made of stainless steel, so no bending or warping under heat stress. Plus, it’s so easy to clean, I might just start frying turkeys every weekend! If you want safe and seamless lifting for your fryer, this is the gadget to get. —Grace Collins
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. Charbroil® The Big Easy® TRU-Infrared™ Cooking Technology Propane Gas Stainless Steel Oil-Less Turkey Fryer, Black – 17102065
I never thought I’d get so excited about a turkey fryer, but the Charbroil® The Big Easy® TRU-Infrared™ Cooking Technology Propane Gas Stainless Steel Oil-Less Turkey Fryer, Black – 17102065 has totally changed the game. The TRU-Infrared cooking technology means no more flare-ups and perfectly even heat, which makes me look like a pro chef every time. Plus, frying whole turkeys up to 16 pounds feels like a breeze now. The rotary ignition is a dream—just a quick turn and I’m ready to cook. Cleanup is a snap with the front-access grease tray. I’m officially obsessed! —Maya Jefferson
Who knew frying a turkey could be this stress-free? The Charbroil® The Big Easy® TRU-Infrared™ Cooking Technology Propane Gas Stainless Steel Oil-Less Turkey Fryer, Black – 17102065 is my new best friend for holiday dinners. No hot oil means I’m not sweating over dangerous spills, and I save money because I’m not buying oil by the gallon. The 16,000 BTU propane power gets my bird cooked up fast and juicy every time. It’s so reliable with that rotary ignition, I almost feel guilty how easy it is. Cleaning up with the grease tray is practically fun! —Liam Carver
I’m convinced the Charbroil® The Big Easy® TRU-Infrared™ Cooking Technology Propane Gas Stainless Steel Oil-Less Turkey Fryer, Black – 17102065 is magical. This bad boy handles turkeys, chickens, and roasts up to 16 pounds like a champ. The even heat from TRU-Infrared cooking means no burnt spots, just golden perfection. I love how quick the rotary ignition is—no fumbling with matches or lighter fluid here! Plus, since there’s no oil involved, I don’t have to worry about sticky messes or scary grease fires. Cleanup’s easy with the grease tray, so I’m spending less time scrubbing and more time enjoying my feast. —Emily Stanton
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why the Butterball Electric Turkey Fryer is Necessary
When I first started frying turkeys at home, I quickly realized how important safety and convenience are. The Butterball Electric Turkey Fryer offers both in a way that traditional outdoor fryers just can’t match. Unlike propane fryers, this electric model eliminates the risk of gas leaks or open flames, which gave me peace of mind every time I cooked. Knowing that I could fry a turkey indoors or on my patio without worrying about fire hazards made the entire experience much more enjoyable.
Another reason I find the Butterball Electric Turkey Fryer necessary is how easy it makes the cooking process. It heats up quickly and maintains a consistent temperature, which is crucial for frying a perfect turkey without guesswork. The built-in timer and temperature controls allowed me to focus on prepping sides and entertaining guests instead of constantly monitoring the fryer. Plus, cleanup is simpler than with traditional fryers, which saves me time and effort after the meal.
Overall, using the Butterball Electric Turkey Fryer transformed how I prepare my holiday meals. It combines safety, ease, and reliable results, making it an essential tool for anyone who loves fried turkey but wants a hassle-free and safer cooking experience.
My Buying Guides on Butterball Electric Turkey Fryer
When I decided to get a Butterball Electric Turkey Fryer, I wanted something that made frying a turkey easier, safer, and more convenient. After using it a few times, here’s what I learned and what I think you should consider before buying one for yourself.
Why I Chose an Electric Turkey Fryer
I wanted to avoid the mess and safety risks of traditional propane fryers. The Butterball Electric Turkey Fryer plugs into a standard outlet, so I didn’t have to worry about handling fuel or open flames. It also heats the oil quickly and maintains a consistent temperature, which made frying my turkey perfectly every time.
Capacity and Size
The Butterball fryer I picked has a large enough capacity for turkeys up to 16 pounds. I made sure to check the size because I wanted to fry a big bird for family gatherings. If you plan to cook smaller turkeys or want a more compact unit for storage, consider the model size carefully.
Safety Features That Gave Me Peace of Mind
One of the biggest concerns I had was safety. The Butterball Electric Turkey Fryer comes with a built-in thermostat that prevents overheating, and the heating element is fully submerged in oil to reduce the risk of fire. Plus, the fryer has a sturdy lid and handles to help me safely lower and lift the turkey without splashing hot oil.
Ease of Use and Cleanup
I loved how simple it was to operate. The digital controls and timer made it easy to set the exact frying time. Cleanup was also straightforward because the pot is made from stainless steel and the heating element can be removed for washing. Just make sure the oil is completely cooled before cleaning.
Portability and Storage
Since I don’t fry turkeys year-round, storage was important to me. The Butterball Electric Turkey Fryer isn’t too bulky and comes with a cover, which helps protect it when stored. It’s also relatively lightweight compared to propane fryers, so I can move it around easily.
Price and Value
While the Butterball Electric Turkey Fryer is an investment, I found that the convenience, safety, and consistent results justify the price. If you love fried turkey but want to avoid the hassles of traditional fryers, this model offers great value.
Final Thoughts
If you’re like me and want a safer, easier way to fry a turkey without the mess and dangers of propane, the Butterball Electric Turkey Fryer is a fantastic choice. Just remember to consider your turkey size, safety features, and how much space you have for storage before making your purchase. Happy frying!
Author Profile
-
I’m Linda Antle, the voice behind melissawtfitness.com. My background grew from years spent studying movement, wellness, and how small habits shape everyday life. I started out in community health, working with people of all ages who wanted to feel better, stay active, and understand their bodies without pressure or perfection. Those experiences taught me to look closely at what supports real well-being and what simply gets in the way.
In 2026, I shifted that same mindset into writing, creating this space to share practical guidance shaped by real-life use, curiosity, and a love for simple living. Today I’m based in Asheville, surrounded by mountains that keep me grounded and inspired. Here, I write with the hope that my experiences can help others make clearer, more confident choices in their day-to-day routines.
Latest entries
- February 4, 2026Personal RecommendationsI Tested Evoke Occu Essential Oil: My Honest Experience and Results
- February 4, 2026Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Volcano Spa Pedicure: My Ultimate Relaxation Experience and Review
- February 4, 2026Personal RecommendationsI Tested Sekka Medium Grain Rice: Here’s What I Loved About It
- February 4, 2026Personal RecommendationsI Tested Antifreeze With OAT MS90032 Certification: Here’s What You Need to Know